This is Interesting: Free Magazines for Graphics designers and webmasters  


Home > Archive > Site Ratings & Reviews > January 2004 > Critique





You are viewing an archived Text-only version of the thread. To view this thread in it's original format and/or if you want to reply to this thread please [click here]

Author Critique
bob adams

2004-01-03, 12:29 am

Please critque www.sctan.com.


Duende

2004-01-03, 1:29 am

While sitting in a puddle bob adams scribbled in the mud:
quote:

> Please critque www.sctan.com.
>


I think that the people in Enoch, Utah should use a Ford van instead of a
Dodge pickup.




--
Duende
The best defense against logic is ignorance.
Farlo

2004-01-03, 3:28 am

"bob adams" <ihatespam@spamersarestupid.com> wrote:
quote:

> www.sctan.com



It looks odd. Also, the content reminds me of PETA fruitcakes.

--
Farlo, the Urban Fey Dragon
Steve R.

2004-01-03, 6:28 am

bob adams wrote in message ...
quote:

> Please critque www.sctan.com.



I gave up after waiting well over half a minute, so can't comment about the
site in general.

Far too many badly-sized (for web) images on that first page.

Steve :~(


Hywel Jenkins

2004-01-03, 7:29 am

In article <Z2rJb.45845$xX.203596@attbi_s02>,
ihatespam@spamersarestupid.com says...
quote:

> Please critque www.sctan.com.



Although the intent of the site is one I support, the site itself is
awful. It doesn't carry the slightest hint of having been designed.

As you've used loads of fixed position <div> elements the page can't be
resized.

if the site works for your cause I guess it's fine, but IMHO it's not
pretty.

--
Hywel I do not eat quiche
http://hyweljenkins.co.uk/
http://hyweljenkins.co.uk/mfaq.php
Sally Thompson

2004-01-03, 7:29 am

On Sat, 03 Jan 2004 03:55:37 GMT, "bob adams"
<ihatespam@spamersarestupid.com> wrote:
quote:

>Please critque www.sctan.com.



I cannot read the blue text on black background on your "webring" box.

--
Sally in Shropshire, UK
http://www.stonybrook-ludlow.co.uk
If you need to email use sally=thompson@btinternet=com and replace the = with a dot
(Reply To is spam trap)
David Dorward

2004-01-03, 7:29 am

bob adams wrote:
quote:

> Please critque www.sctan.com.



Absolute positioning to place variable size elements vertically below each
other considered harmful: <http://dorward.me.uk/tmp/sctan.png>

.... and your HTML and CSS is invalid.

--
David Dorward <http://dorward.me.uk/>
JustAnotherGuy

2004-01-03, 10:29 am

Farlo wrote:
quote:

> "bob adams" <ihatespam@spamersarestupid.com> wrote:
>
>
>
>
> It looks odd. Also, the content reminds me of PETA fruitcakes.



Heh. Twenty years from now, you'll be the bigoted fruitcake :p

Farlo

2004-01-03, 12:28 pm

JustAnotherGuy <JustAnotherGuy@mailinator.com> wrote:

I distinguish between Animal Rights people like myself and PETA nutjobs.
That doesn't make me a bigot, it makes me an independant thinker.

--
Farlo, the Urban Fey Dragon
kchayka

2004-01-03, 12:28 pm

David Dorward <dorward@yahoo.com> wrote in message news:<bt682m$37k$1$8302bc10@news.demon.co.uk>...
quote:

> bob adams wrote:
>
>
> Absolute positioning to place variable size elements vertically below each
> other considered harmful: <http://dorward.me.uk/tmp/sctan.png>
>
> ... and your HTML and CSS is invalid.



<meta name="generator" content="Created Using Yahoo! PageBuilder
2.61.84">

I think it's safe to blame the tool for everything that's wrong with
the design and code. These online (so-called) WYSIWYG editors are
pretty darned appealing to the poor saps who sign up for them. The
creators of these tools don't give a rat's arse about anything except
sucking these poor saps in. The saps obviously don't know any better,
if they did they surely wouldn't use tools like this.

BTW, I didn't realize the old GeoCities editor had evolved into this
abomination. Be afraid. What's worse is this abomination has a twin:
homestead.com.
gmanon

2004-01-06, 11:29 am

* Page too long
* I personally don't like backgrounds.
* Menu not intuitive. It's actually, hard to find.
* Elements disorganized.
* No categories or subtitle for links.
* Monotone


bob adams wrote:
quote:

> Please critque www.sctan.com.
>
>



Sponsored Links


Copyright 2003 - 2008 forum4designers.com  Software forum  Computer Hardware reviews